Audit my site →

Nonprofits & community

Nine in ten reach the donation page and leave

Small charities, churches, community groups. Getting someone onto the donation page is the expensive part. It is also not the part that is failing.

Of the people who reach a primary donation page, M+R’s 2026 benchmarks report that 11% of desktop visitors and 8% of mobile visitors complete a gift. Round it and roughly nine in ten arrive and leave.

Most of that nine is not recoverable, and no source says otherwise. People browse, compare, change their minds, mean to come back.

What the benchmarks do establish is the shape of the funnel: reaching the donation page is the hard part, and M+R’s panel averaged $2.81 per lead from digital advertising. Whatever share of the nine is down to the page itself is worth knowing, and it is cheap to find out.

Mobile is the hinge

Across M+R’s panel, mobile users were 52% of all visits, and the average gift was $88 on mobile against $168 on desktop.

More than half the visits come from the device that converts lower and gives less per gift. Those are panel averages, not a measurement of your page — but they do say which device to read your donation form on first.

The accessibility problem is a mission problem

WebAIM tested one million home pages in 2026. 95.9% had detected WCAG failures, averaging 56.1 errors per page — and the number of detected errors rose 10.1% against the 2025 analysis. The three commonest: low contrast text (83.9%), missing image alt text (53.1%), and missing form input labels (51%).

WebAIM measured home pages, not donation forms. But an unlabelled input is the kind of error that makes a form hard or impossible to complete with a screen reader, and a donation form is nothing but inputs. For an organisation whose purpose is including people, that is worth one afternoon of checking.

The legal position is real too — the Department of Justice publishes its own guidance on how the ADA applies to web content — but it is the second reason, not the first.

Donors check you before they give

A first-time donor who cannot tell from your page what their money does will not write to ask. They will close the tab, and you will never see it in any report.

What we do

A persona with a reading level, a patience level and a phone walks your donation path and reports where it lost them — by step, not as a score.

What we found on 38 nonprofit sites

Performance
60.9/100
SEO
81.4/100
Accessibility
83.1/100

48 scans across 38 sites, average score 67.7. 26 of those scans graded D or F. Figures pulled 2026-11-09.

What a review of a nonprofit site covers

Scoped to the path a donor actually walks, because that is where the evidence says the money is.

  • The donation path, step by step: landing page to donate page to form to confirmation, each one read separately rather than judging the home page alone.
  • Most personas on phones, to match the 52% mobile share M+R reports across its panel.
  • A WCAG error report scoped to the donation and volunteer forms, calling out the failures that make a gift impossible rather than merely annoying.
  • A plain-language pass on the ask itself: whether a first-time donor can tell what their money does, in a sentence.

What you can do about it

Free scan One persona reads your homepage and tells you what stopped them. No card. Free Start free
Human design review Adam reads the page himself, draws how it should look, and talks it through on a call. $499 Ask about it

Every step includes the ones under it, so the price you see is the whole price. Stripe will ask which website to review — the report lands by email once it is written. Want to see the free read first? Start there.

Where these numbers come from

  • M+R Benchmarks 2026, website performance — 11% of desktop users who landed on a primary donation page completed a gift, 8% for mobile. Nonprofits received an average of $1.33 per visitor. Average gift $168 on desktop against $88 on mobile. Mobile users were 52% of all visits.
  • M+R Benchmarks 2026, advertising — The average cost per lead for digital advertising was $2.81. A lead is not the same as a site visit; the page says cost per lead.
  • WebAIM Million 2026 — One million home pages tested: 95.9% had detected WCAG 2 failures, averaging 56.1 errors per page, up 10.1% year over year. Top three failures are low contrast text (83.9%), missing alt text (53.1%) and missing form input labels (51%).
  • US Department of Justice, web accessibility guidance — The DOJ's own statement of how the ADA applies to web content.